One of the most expensive paintings ever offered at auction will go under the hammer as planned on Wednesday night, after Sotheby's settled a restitution dispute over its star lot at the last minute. The auction house announced on Tuesday morning that the family selling the work and the descendants of Samuel Fischer had found common ground, ending a claim that had hung over the entire New York sale week.

The painting at the centre of the row is Vincent van Gogh's Chataigniers en fleurs, painted in 1890 and valued at around $180 million, far above the artist's existing auction record of $117.2 million. The Fischer heirs argued that the family parted with the canvas in Amsterdam in 1936 because Nazi persecution left them little choice. Sotheby's maintains that its research found no evidence the sale was forced, and that the price paid at the time matched the market. The terms of the settlement have not been disclosed.

The dispute surfaced publicly only last week, when the New York Times reported the heirs' demand that the picture be withdrawn. That left Sotheby's with little time: the canvas leads a dozen lots from the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, assembled over decades by Argentine sugar magnate Carlos Pedro Blaquier and his wife Nelly, and the house has guaranteed all twelve. Rival Christie’s had already flagged the painting as high risk when pitching for the consignment, using its own traffic-light system for works that may have passed through Europe between 1933 and 1945.

The episode shows how far the ground has shifted on Nazi-era claims. Guidelines adopted in 2024 now cover sales made under duress, not only outright confiscation, and American law changed this year to block delay-based defences against timely claims. Only days ago, a Paris court annulled a 2024 Sotheby's sale of a Pissarro after heirs who had not been consulted challenged it. Dealers said the Van Gogh could hardly have fetched a record price while a claim remained open, since no buyer wants to wonder whether the seller's children might one day come after them.