Sotheby's daytime contemporary sale in New York closed on 17 November with a total of $83.03 million, a day after the house's two evening auctions brought in a combined $378.7 million. The session showed a market that rewards the right lot handsomely while leaving plenty behind: 47 percent of works sold above their high estimates, 38 percent landed inside their estimate ranges, and 15 percent fell below their low estimates.

The top price went to Fernando Botero's Mother and Child, painted in 1979, which sold for $3.41 million, 89 percent above its $1.8 million low estimate. The painting carried a guarantee and had changed hands three times before. The sharpest surprise of the afternoon was Alexander Calder's On the Four Quadrants, a 1944 work that had been valued at just $30,000 and instead made $236,800, nearly eight times that figure.

Five artists set new auction records. John Kacere's Laura II, from 1993, sold for $704,000, more than five times the artist's previous best. Nigel Cooke's Smoking Lovers reached $320,000, Luchita Hurtado's untitled 1971 painting made $102,400, Emma Reyes's untitled 1983 work sold for $83,200, and Ming Fay's Cherry fetched $38,400. Guarantees underpinned 40 lots, including Wayne Thiebaud's Ocean City, which sold for $3.29 million, 31 percent above its low estimate.

The sale was far from a clean sweep. Fifty-four works failed to sell, among them a 1968 Mark Rothko estimated at $3.5 million to $5 million, and nine lots were withdrawn before bidding began, including a 2006 Wade Guyton estimated at $1 million to $1.5 million. All reported prices include buyer's premium.