Market dispatch·Cologne
Lempertz Presses Ahead With Sale of Gothic Panels as Heirs of Jewish Dealer Say They Were Stolen
Cologne auction house Lempertz has refused to halt Saturday's sale of two Johann Koerbecke altarpiece panels, estimated at about 300,000 euros each, after the foundation for the heirs of German Jewish dealer Max Stern claimed the works were stolen and demanded the sale stop until two competing ownership claims are resolved.

The Cologne auction house Lempertz is pressing ahead with the sale of two fifteenth-century altarpiece panels this Saturday, despite a demand from the heirs of a German Jewish art dealer that the sale be stopped. Johann Koerbecke's The Annunciation and The Vision of Saint Bernard, likely from the Marienfeld high altarpiece completed in 1457, are the most expensive works in the house's Old Masters sale, with high estimates of around 300,000 euros each. They are to be offered individually and then as a pair.
The Dr. Max and Iris Stern Foundation, acting for the heirs of the dealer Max Stern, says the panels were stolen and has called on Lempertz to halt the sale until two distinct ownership claims by different victims are resolved in line with the Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art. Stern held the paintings in Dusseldorf between 1936 and 1937, the year the Nazis closed his gallery, after which they passed, according to Lempertz's provenance, to the Dusseldorf dealer Hans Bammann. The foundation points out that both works appear in the Interpol Database of Stolen Art and are listed on the German Lost Art Database as Nazi-confiscated property, a claim it registered in 2018.
The case is complicated by a second, earlier claim. Before Stern, the panels belonged to Ellen Funke, who was classified under the Nazi regime as a Mischling because of Jewish ancestry through her mother and sold her collection in 1936 to fund her emigration. In 2025, Bavaria's state museums returned The Vision of Saint Bernard to Funke's heirs, and Cologne's Kolumba Art Museum returned The Annunciation to them as well. Funke's heirs are listed as the sellers on Lempertz's website. The Stern Foundation argues that the rights of both Jewish victims must be considered and that restitution to Funke's heirs alone did not produce a just and fair solution.
Lempertz has said it will not cancel the sale. A representative said the house follows current restitution practice and the recommendations of the German federal government, maintained that the paintings had not been taken from Stern, and argued that Stern had been compensated after the war while Funke's heirs had not. The house did not dispute the stolen-art listings, but noted that they record the restitutions already made. The dispute now turns on whether a sale can go ahead while two families' claims to the same panels remain unresolved.


