Two landscape architecture students at Harvard University's Graduate School of Design have drawn up alternative visions for Memorial Circle in Washington, DC, the site where President Donald Trump wants to build a 250-foot triumphal arch. Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner developed their proposals with The Cultural Landscape Foundation, after taking a seminar taught by the foundation's president, Charles Birnbaum.

Both designs replace the traffic roundabout with broad pools of water and restore the emphasis on the site's historic processional axis, with clear sightlines to the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery. The first proposal fills the central circle with a low-lying pool, treating the space as an open void along the axis between Washington and Arlington. The second removes the circle altogether and inserts a straight thoroughfare leading to Arlington Memorial Bridge.

The proposals are a direct response to a project that has drawn sustained opposition. The administration's arch, designed by Harrison Design, would stand 250 feet tall and, by the government's own admission, block historically significant views between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington. During the legally required Section 106 review, officials refused to consider alternative sites, and the review process was later terminated.

The legal fight continues: a federal judge halted construction in early November, hours after the National Capital Planning Commission approved the final plans. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum has said the arch would reinforce the corridor's ceremonial role as a gateway between Washington and Arlington National Cemetery. The students' designs offer a different reading of that same corridor — one built around water, openness and public access rather than a single towering monument.