Market dispatch·United States
$165,000 Haring Drawing Rejected by Both Big Auction Houses — Court Rules Gallery Breached Its Warranty Anyway
A Connecticut court has ruled that a Keith Haring subway drawing bought for $165,000 in 2018 breached the sale's warranty of merchantability because Christie's and Sotheby's both refused it for auction over provenance, even though the buyer waited too long to sue and the claim was dismissed.

A collector who paid $165,000 for a Keith Haring subway drawing has won a striking legal point and lost his case at the same time. On 25 August 2026, a Connecticut Superior Court judge decided that the drawing, known as the Saucer Drawing, breached the implied warranty of merchantability in its sale, yet dismissed the buyer's claim because it was filed too late.
Vernon Adam Hartung bought the work in 2018 from Martin Lawrence Galleries. The invoice carried an express promise that any work described without qualification as by a named artist was authentic. Trouble surfaced three years later, when Hartung tried to sell the drawing and both Christie's and Sotheby's turned it down. Each house said the work failed its internal checks for Haring subway drawings: it had neither published literature nor an exhibition history, and it did not appear in the photographic archive compiled by Haring's contemporary Tseng Kwong Chi.
Haring produced as many as 5,000 of these quick chalk drawings in New York subway stations during the 1980s, and the Tseng Kwong Chi archive, holding around 3,000 images of them, has become a key reference for the trade. The judge found that because the two leading auction houses would not handle the drawing, it could not pass in the market without objection, and the merchantability warranty was therefore breached even though the sellers had not acted in bad faith.
The victory proved hollow. The court held that Hartung had brought his claim outside the permitted time, so it was dismissed despite being otherwise sound. Hartung has appealed. The ruling underlines a hard lesson for buyers of street-era work: a piece can be genuine and still be effectively unsellable if its paper trail does not satisfy the auction houses that set the market's terms.

