Market dispatch·New York
Bic Heirs' $3M Chauffeur-Theft Claim Over a Fra Angelico Survives Bid to Kill the Case
A New York judge has refused to dismiss a lawsuit in which the heirs to the Bic pen fortune allege their chauffeur stole a Fra Angelico painting and sold it to dealer Richard Feigen for $3 million.

A New York judge has refused to throw out a lawsuit over a 15th-century Fra Angelico painting that the heirs to the Bic pen fortune say was stolen by their family chauffeur and later sold by the late dealer Richard Feigen. In a decision dated 26 October and filed on 16 November, Justice James G. Clynes rejected an attempt by Feigen's estate and associated businesses to dismiss the case, chiefly on the grounds that the family had waited too long to sue.
The dispute centres on Saint Sixtus, painted around 1453 to 1455. Baron Marcel Bich, founder of the Bic pen company, bought it at Sotheby's in 1972 for £130,000; it later passed to his son Bruno Bich. A lawsuit filed in March 2026 by Bruno's three sons alleges the family chauffeur, Roy Morrow, took the painting around 2006 and sold it to Feigen for $3 million without proof of ownership. Feigen, who died in 2021, insured it for $8.5 million and later consigned it to Christie's, where it sold in 2018 for $5.4 million to the Chilean billionaire Álvaro Saieh and his wife, Ana Guzmán, who own it today.
The judge has not decided who owns the painting, or even whether it was stolen, and stressed that New York law on stolen art is complex. But he found too many unanswered questions about Feigen's purchase to end the case now, and he temporarily set aside the defence argument that the family's delay should bar the claim, noting that it could be revisited later. Feigen's estate did win one partial victory: claims against his revocable trust and its trustees were dismissed for lack of evidence connecting the trust to the sale proceeds, though the family may refile with more proof.
The current owners maintain that they bought the painting in good faith, relying on Christie's research, and say they will defend their rights vigorously. For the Bich family, the ruling is an important step toward recovering a work their lawyer described as a treasured possession that no family should lose simply because the people who handled it were sophisticated dealmakers.


