Market dispatch·Global
Artnet's Auction-Betting Deal With Kalshi Draws Mockery Online While Advisers Stay Divided
Artnet's partnership with prediction-market platform Kalshi, announced on 11 November, has drawn swift scorn from artists and curators on Instagram, while art advisers are more divided about whether betting on auction results has any use for collectors.

Artnet has become the official art partner of Kalshi, the prediction-market platform, in a deal announced on Wednesday. Artnet will help choose the subjects of art-related betting markets and supply the auction data from its Price Database that settles wagers, while Kalshi designs the contracts and runs the exchange. Artnet says its newsroom will play no part in the markets. The deal lands days before New York's November marquee sales, and follows Kalshi's move into art markets in May.
The reaction on Instagram was swift and unsparing. Marcella Zimmerman, chief executive of arts PR firm Digital Counsel, asked whether the announcement was an April Fool's joke. Curator Joshua Decter called it truly pathetic, describing Kalshi as a gambling platform under investigation by regulators. Jasmine Wahi of the Project for Empty Space wrote that the deal showed how easily art could be reduced to an asset to be liquidated. Artist Gabriel Allred called it a disappointment and warned of media-driven manipulation, while Artnet columnist Kenny Schachter posted a satirical image of himself in a casino surrounded by artworks.
Live markets already cover the coming sales. Contracts on Yoshitomo Nara's Candy Blue Night, headed to Sotheby's on 16 November, ask whether it will sell for more or less than $6 million or $7 million, with further contracts on works by Bacon, Warhol and Lichtenstein. A market on Sotheby's Blaquier-Arrieta sale gave it about a 52 per cent chance of passing $500 million, on just $372 traded.
Advisers were less categorical. Wendy Cromwell, founder of advisory firm Cromwell Art and a former Sotheby's specialist, saw a way for art-world followers who are not collectors to take part, while warning that insider knowledge would make the markets extraordinarily tempting. Philip Hoffman of the Fine Art Group said he could not see a great use for collectors, recalling a de Kooning he had guaranteed for well over $10 million that he sold for $9.7 million, a $300,000 loss. The deal follows Artnet's merger with Artsy seven months ago. Cromwell's verdict: listening to prediction markets is a fool's game.


